Army reserve vs marine reserve reddit Remember, your journey in the Marines vs Army decision starts with understanding, introspection, and making the choice that aligns best with your goals and values. I’m a reservist (never AD except for a six month mobilization in seven years) and used the GI Bill both before and after the mobilization. From what they told me the marines corps life is rough with little pay off. Depends on the job and the state When people think of Marines they think of the persona from Call of Duty/Battlefield video games and all the attention they get from war movies and media coverage. Something in addition to everything else to consider (Army reserve perspective here): if you join the reserves and drill for points only, after three months you get automatically coded as a nonparticipant. If it’s really all about paying for college - go Air Force. The Reserve provides and maintains qualified and trained units for active duty when necessary. I I have not heard back in 3 months. A big motivation for me joining was for clout… but I could never go active duty. Looking at Guard and Reserves but want to know chances of getting to serve overseas. You may want to check out the Army National Guard. S. In fact, I had no comprehension at We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. ***Please use a clear title for your question: clear titles get clear answers. I’d like to join the military just to experience something new and make memories before I go to college. Reserves are a completely different We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I imagine Royal Marines training is more frequent, but other than that are there any tangible differences? Thank you! Nobody joins the reserves for money or the benefits—at least not Marines reserves. Marines Reserves Or Army Reserves I'm going to be joining the reserves soon because I want to have a civilian job after boot camp, and I want to be able to see my parents and grandma more before she dies. They can also be activated and deployed during wartime. Which branch has a better reserve component? You're leaving out a couple branches there. Army. Some units just meet 1 weekend a month and 2 weeks for annual AT while ive known other units to be in emergency deployment lists to do foreign and domestic missions at a few days notice. I'm a Senior in highschool, and have been in JROTC for all 4 years, but don't know if I want to do National Guard or Reserves. The reason I am thinking reserves is because of many opinions I've read about how bad being in the marines can be and I think I will be content with just serving in the reserves. Anyway, to answer your question, I've worked alongside USCG-R folks and they kept mentioning how tons of training comes out of their own pocket. The reserves is cool and all, but it works best when members served on active duty beforehand. Active to Reserves, Retirement questions I will have 13 years of active duty time by the time I ETS. Five years Air Force and 12 years Army (so far). A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community Reserves doesn’t get any benefits aside from tricare reserves. What are the differences between the two, as well as pros and cons and benefits? The U. 7 to 4 during drill and when your done you're done. The other big difference, at least in active duty, is that your initial few jobs looks a bit different. Honest opinions of Army Vs Navy Vs Airforce Tldr: help me pick between Army Navy and Airforce. If you value customs and courtesies, tradition, and a more military like experience - go Army or Marines. Its more like cosplaying than it is a military branch. The Army Reserve allows you to pursue a civilian career or attend college full-time and still serve your community and What were your experiences with MP reserves? They do a lot of police work or were you more of a “multi-purpose” unit? Share your experiences because I am interested! 278K subscribers in the army community. Have you asked on any of the subreddits for doctors? In the marines it seems that lower ranks have much more responsibility than other branches, but get promoted slower. If you’re competent and want it, you’ll rapidly move into leadership positions. In the AF you do your job and that's it. If reserves is your aim, national guard (Air Force or Army) are exactly what you’re looking for. For people who serve in the reserves, what obligations did you have to meet and any advice or opinions? What’s the pay difference between active duty, reserve, national guard, and enlisted vs officer? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The Army Reserve of today ties directly to the earlier Medical Reserve Corps. A sub for anyone to ask questions about the military. I was in the army for 6 years and I met a ton of dudes that came from the marines, very rarely did they do more than one contract in the marines. Once you are in a job, you are basically set in that position until you either pass away or retire. You will collect the pension at 60, minus any years of reserve deployments you go through. Mar 15, 2024 路 Discover the Key Differences Between Active Duty and Reserves in the U. Make them a PowerPoint or something, they'll make you a fucking Commodore or some shit. Im prior active duty army (3 years), been in the NG for 4 years, and im gettin tired of the way things work half-assed and unmotivated here. For Reserves/Guard you choose a specific job at a specific unit, it’s not “any job you qualify for and we send you wherever” like Active. a 6 year enlistment in the reserves or guard qualifies you for the MGIB-SR Chapter 1606. Not everyone goes into the IRR, but pretty much everyone's contract includes some IRR time. (There are exceptions). It depends. TRICARE Reserve select for your family when there's trouble or you're between jobs. Reserves, including pay, duty stations, daily life, and service commitment length. If you're talking full time Army vs Army Reserves, then it's better to do full time Army if you have no plan whatsoever for your civilian side. It’s the most elite thing I could have become. As an Army reservist, you don't get the National Guard nonsense, just federal callups. The money made in the reserves was not worth the loss of salary and days off from a civilian job. It might be 4 years Active, or 6 years Reserve/Guard, with the remaining amount in the IRR We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The guard are great but it miss the Esprit de corps in the Marines, that make the toxic part bearable. Why don’t you try the army reserves for a couple of years - get a bit of military and civilian work experience that will help develop your mental robustness, whilst also giving you a little bit of a taste of military life. Jan 6, 2023 路 What’s the Difference Between National Guard and Reserves? You’re going to find plenty of similarities when comparing the National Guard vs. What's the difference in experience between Active Duty vs. A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community army reserves versus air force reserves My wife asked if she should join the reserves before she ‘ages out’ I know nothing about the reserves. Location for current, potential, and veteran soldiers and airmen of the US National Guard. The navy looks appealing since I’d be able to travel around the world, but the bond between marines seems like no other. Reserves, including the fact that, technically, the Army National Guard and the Reserves are both part of the U. The army has great benefits for education from the gi bill and We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Jun 19, 2024 路 Read this guide to find out how to switch from Reserves to Active Duty for the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps and the Coast Guard. You will learn more soldier stuff than your actual job. They usually drill one weekend a month, with a couple weeks of annual training in the summer. The pay looks kinda shit tbh but it seems like quite the adventure tbh. As I been talking with recruiters from Army Reserve for 2 weeks now. Each reserve also has different physical requirements, training times, and expectations, so it's a good idea to research these aspects thoroughly. Militaryfaq) submitted 2 hours ago by 馃う鈾傦笍Civilian UrdnotSnarf I’m 34 with a bachelor’s degree. For example, every initial military contract is 8 years. Mar 19, 2025 路 I'm 20 looking to join the reserves immediately. I know the career opportunities are different based on the Mission set Jun 18, 2024 路 The military reserves allows individuals to remain close to home, while providing a service to their country. Additionally does anybody know where I can request a member 4 DD214? I submitted a request online but was told it was forwarded to the USMC. I want to join a 4yr union electrical inside wireman apprenticeship this fall, so in the mean time I would like to go ahead and enlist in the reserves for the marines. What I dislike about being a reservist is trying to balance your civilian life/job with the army, especially if you have an additional duty or have to attend a course thats needed for your career, you have to take time off from your civilian job. If I transition into the reserves, how is my retirement calculated? When can I collect, and how many years do I need to serve in the reserves? I have tried searching but I just come across a bunch of poorly written blogs. ***"The military" is vague. Access to your state benefits being in the reserves and when you're on active duty - you may even qualify for some being a reservist. Is this process easier in the other branches or is it the same level of difficulty throughout the different branches. According to this subreddit, national guard has extremely slow promotion + old boys club, while reserve is unorganized + understaffed, then overall, which branch do you recommend for an officer? A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community Hello y’all I wanted to find out if the national guard deploys more than the army reserve to or it all depends on the mos you choose? I’m a civil engineer and want to do something engineering in the army. Sure you’ll get a million crayon jokes but I’ve meet a ton of good people. But generally Air Force and Navy tend to be a bit more law firm-like, and the Army and Marines tend to have a bit more emphasis on treating JAGs more like normal service members. Anyone that signs up for the Marines and chooses to serve on active duty must serve 4 years of active service. The VA recently gave me a 50% disability rating and payment dated back to Dec 2021 after I got off active duty orders. Marine B: Does 20 years reserves, 1 deployment Jun 18, 2024 路 What is the Army Reserves and Army National Guard and what are the differences? Find information on Army Reserves, the National Guard and 5 key differences. Although both active and reserve have their pros/cons, these are very shit reasons as to not being a reservist. I never graduated bct after an injury (stress fracture then hernia). Learn more about military reserves options. Almost 20 years in and was an E5 due to changing uniforms so many times. military reserve forces. She’s got 2 doctorates Phd/JD. A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community Hi guys and gals, I’m wondering what the differences between Air Force and Army reserves are. org Regret joining National Guard over Marine Reserves. I have an itch to join the military and am considering marines or army. I know the National guard and army reserves has their own but was never give a separate one for the marines. Specify Army, Navy, etc. (“Former Marine” vs “he was in the Army”). United States Army on Reddit What are the major differences of Active duty and Reserves? Besides the obvious home more often in the reserve, what really are the differences? The only reason why im considering going into the reserve is because I have my only brother with me who I don’t want to leave along and a now a relationship. Served in 6 reserve units over the last 10 years, as I’ve moved around the country and overseas. I understand you can’t double dip with the VA disability and drill pay and can only chose to collect one or the other. The army reserve is a great way to serve part time. I’m an Officer now and I still don’t think it would be worth it. Service Commitment The biggest difference between the reserves and active duty Marines lies in the commitment to service. I know some national guard units do more live fire training exercises than some active army units and some that deploy more. Should you go active duty or would the Marine Forces Reserve be better for you? Jun 19, 2024 路 Read this guide to find out how to switch from Reserves to Active Duty for the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps and the Coast Guard. Reserve\Guard What are the Pros and Cons of Enlisted vs Officer in the Army Reserve aside from pay and benefits? (self. - The Marine Corps Reserve is ideal if you are looking for a challenge and would like to serve in combat and ground combat elements. Marine Reserves commit 4 years of inactive service. Reserve GI Bill is $400ish a month while you are in school, vs the Post 9/11 GI Bill which is tuition plus BAH. Jan 29, 2025 路 Now that you have reached the conclusion of our article on active duty vs reserve, you should be able to answer questions, like do Army reserves get deployed and make detailed comparisons for Army reserve vs active duty, enlisted vs reserves, and active duty vs national guard. How hard would it be to go from Army National Guard to Air Guard or Reserves? I’m a Marine veteran who served active duty from 2011-2015, graduated… A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community The Inactive Ready Reserve is supposed to be a pool of people that can be quickly called up when necessary, but more slowly than Reserve or National Guard. I came from active duty to the reserves so I have all of my veteran benefits. I was Army national guard and now I'm AF reserve. Remember, also, that the reserves aren't just a job – they're a commitment to serving your country, which comes with responsibilities. A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions… I am currently full-time law enforcement, who is seeking to join either army reserve or national guard. Military! Uncover the benefits, lifestyle, and commitments of both parties. I only did 5 active and then nearly 5 reserves, but have no document showing my reserve time. The Marine Corps JROTC offers valuable insights into the Marine Corps’s values and training, which could be an excellent starting point for your exploration. If this irrelevant shit is important to you, join the fucking navy, they thrive on irrelevant candy-ass bullshit. I had read that the marines have reserves, but I think for officers you have to do a full 4 or 6 years active duty and then request to join the reserves. Army is the most powerful and sophisticated military force in the world and Army Reserve is one of three components in the U. Read more in details below. I haven’t looked at navy ratings yet but if I were to join the marines, I’d probably try to be a combat You also have to ask about the different elements, because Air reserves work very differently from Army Reserves and the Navy is different from the other two. So from a financial point of view is there any benefit or incentive to Found out my job offers pay bumps for military service. This is basically when someone is on the books yet isn't drawing pay. If you decide you like the infanteering aspects of it, then apply for the Royal Marines, you’ll be 20 years old. Jun 19, 2024 路 Learn about the major differences of Active Duty vs. Plus if you go Army and don't like the challenge, you can always go Ranger for something way more high speed than regular infantry will offer you in either. I was medically discharged after 8 months and did college and civ life. Armed Forces' operational force. Army Reserve vs NY National Guard My family finally agreed on joining an army (part time). The active-duty Army is pretty straightforward. Asked this in Natl Guard reddit, wanted to hear from the Reserve Marines here. Long version: I originally joined the army back in 2008ish. So, there is an Army Reserve, Marine Corps Reserve, Navy Reserve, Air Force Reserve, and Coast Guard Reserve. To compare benefits the reserve GI bill is ass compared to the active duty one. - The Coast Guard Reserve offers roles related to maritime safety, security, and environmental protection. I'll agree the Army has less of the culture of pride than the Marines (which I actually prefer because it's cringe as hell half the time) but we definitely have the brotherhood. Well the Marine Corps reserve is all the toxinsness of the Marine Corps incore minus deployments. A subreddit for all of those in, interested in or have served in the British Armed Forces of any branch. Your active experience yields professionalism few reservists can emulate. Every flightline job (which is most of the Air Jan 10, 2025 路 That can be disruptive for students. I’ve always wanted to join the army but everyone keeps telling me to join the Air Force. It’s easy to stand out as a prior Marine. Aug 13, 2018 路 What is the difference between Army and Marine infantry reserves - culturally, logistically, frequency of deployment, or otherwise? Do Marine reservists ever deploy to serve a rotation on a ship? See full list on operationmilitarykids. The only issue would be having to take off at least a semester of school to complete basic (10 weeks), OCS (14 weeks) and then my specific MOS training. 5K subscribers in the armyreserve community. I’m honestly just looking for good training. Yes, the Air Force has moslty less physical jobs. Ive always appreciated the spirit of the marine corps and would like to join it, but im curious if this is a “grass is greener on the other side” situation or if i should just switch from an HHC What is the process of transferring from the Marine Reserves into Active Duty? How difficult is it, and have you seen someone do this? Everyone only keeps talking about how hard it is. Education benefits and promotion opportunities will be better in the Army. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Hi - Looking for advice on what the difference between the two are regarding the reserves squad commitments. I’m a prior service marine thinking about enlisting into either the reserves or guard as a 12B. A few things: Reserves after AD is almost universally cake walk. My goal was to become as elite as l possibly could (I’m physically unable to do anything like Rangers, SEALS or SF because of flat feet pain). Was a Marine then switched to AF and then switched to Army and then went to Navy Reserve. I got call from NY National Guard today and ask me to join with them instead of Army Reserve. If you're talking Army Reserves vs Civilian, I think Reserves is a great choice to help you pay for college and give you some good resume bullets for civilian job search. The guard on the other hand will match state school rates so you would probably get more for school wise from the guard. Discover what they have in common, how they are different, and which one you should join. I turn in the application they gave me but I haven't commit anything yet. 5. And all of the reserves are under the command of their respective service branch. A lot of people tell me I should try for officer, but the MOS that interest me most (46V and 46S) are enlisted only. We had reservist with more deployments than their active duty counterparts. By sheer number of personnel and operational capacity. There’s absolutely no point in going marine reserves in my opinion. The point of joining the marines in my eyes is to live the life and actually do it everyday. It sounds like you'll probably regret not earning that title if you join any other branch. . New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Is there a world for her in the reserves? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. What Are the Reserves? The Reserves (or Army Reserve, Navy Reserve, Air Force Reserve, Marine Corps Reserve, and Coast Guard Reserve) are part of the U. The Army Reserves are the reserve component of the federal active-duty Army. 6. If there's any differences between the benefits you receive for going active vs Reserve? Archived post. Army Reserve: With about 200,000 personnel, this branch supports active-duty forces with flexibility and expertise. I was a Marine Corps ground officer before going to law school so I can't offer any insight into being a JAG, but unless you specifically want to be a Marine, one of the other branches would probably be a more logical choice. Those who are very savvy with a reserve retirement is it really worth it? Army National Guard: Approximately 336,000 dedicated members bolster both state and national efforts. Many people did not mind that because the retirement. Should you go active duty or would the Marine Forces Reserve be better for you? Mar 19, 2019 路 Here are the differences between reserve and active duty Marines. Examples: Marine A: Does 8 years AD and 12 years reserves. I did get an honorable discharge though. You also get access to the state benefits and federal benefits in the Guard whereas you only get federal benefits in the AD Army or the Army Reserve. This subreddit is for questions about the British Armed Forces, experiences (plenty of sandbags to sit on for war stories), and anything else. United States Army on Reddit Jun 19, 2024 路 Wondering what the differences between the US Army vs. This is a common "grass is greener" idea. A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions… Army: grunts, basically a less hardo marines Air Force: smart but boring in every aspect: where you get stationed, jobs (except pilot obv), not really a “tough” job compared to the rest of the branches We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. US Marine Corps are? Learn more about the similiarities and differences between both branches. I also like the “tough” aspect of the marines. She’s been a licensed attorney passed bar in July 2020. My Army recruiter was actually a former Marine from my reserve unit. ***Your post must be a question; chat posts are not allowed. Marine Corps Reserves supplement active-duty Marines during battle. I am currently working with a Marine recruiter. The reason the Marines grabbed me was because: - Their reserves has infantry - They get to deploy to more coastal areas, and do land and sea missions which I'm more interested in - And it is a bit of a dream, but I feel like I could find a way to go train in Hawaii or go to Hawaii for the marines for some reason just so I can go to Hawaii Marine infantry is going to feel the same as Army infantry, except you're a Marine getting promoted slower. Click to explore everything you need to know between the two to find out which option best suits you! In the process of enlisting and interested in the Civil Affairs MOS. I say this solely because (unless things have changed) the Marines puts all its officers, JAGs and pilots included, through the same basic training courses so you'd be I don’t know how the Army reserve works but Marine side, you could jump on deployments, or TAD by talking to MOBCOM. The army national guard might pay more for school than both of your options On the other hand, going active duty seems like the full "military experience". Jun 20, 2025 路 Job Certification for the National Guard & Reserve Depending on the branch of military service, the nature of your career field, and whether you serve in the National Guard or the Reserve, you may be offered job certification that is related to your military job. The endgame benefits are better in AD, but Reserve they are not. Learn more about the Army National Guard vs Army Reserve. They collect a pension at 60, but those 8 years worth of points plus the 12 years of reserve points factor into how much they get. Which is more likely to deploy to Iraq, Afghanistan, or Syria, an infantry company in the Marine Reserve or an infantry company in the Army National Guard? I’ve been a USMC drilling reservist since 2013 with one deployment last year. So talk to an NG recruiter, Army Reserve recruiter, Marine recruiter, etc and ask them to lay out what units are within commuting distance of you and what kinds of jobs those units have available. And if you transfer over after already being in the reserves for 2 years and decide to Jan 29, 2025 路 The Reserve is a component of every military service branch. I have a few questions. Or the difference between each branch that has reserved. Air force reserve gives you 4500 a year which with the cost of college now might not get you very far. The army also does things backwards and by the numbers. Historically, the reserves were created to fill the need for trained doctors. A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community. 9K subscribers in the armyreserve community. If you are asking about the Post 9/11 GI Bill, that's earned through qualifying Active Duty service. People don't pull rank for dumb reasons or yell orders. Both recruiters have said that they're better. Learn more about different enlistment contracts, options, and types. Why do active duty marines act like its such an accomplishment and so hard to not be fat, especially without morning PT? Believe it or not, there’s people out there besides AD Marines who aren’t fat and exercise for fun/hobby. Marine Corps Active-Duty: Housing 186,000 Marines, this branch is known for its rigorous training and rapid response capabilities. Most guards have way better fringe benefits that would make a reserve contract far more enticing and worth it than being a Marine. I like being in the field and getting my hands dirty and I think a one weekend a month is manageable for me. But, the Air Force also has much less military career opportunities as a whole. Reserves, specifically: Mission Job lifeline (I've heard that Active Duty CA's future is declining) Productivity (how much you actually do your job) Frequency of deployments Treatment from higher ups / within the team / with rest of army Quality of life I was We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. . Everyone lives in the state so it’s easy to build comradery and network for jobs. Get insights into career opportunities, deployment, and flexibility. A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. However; Depending on your unit and mos it can kind of depend on how active you are. There’s less bullshit with more money and bonuses. The Army will definitely toughen you up and make you resilient. They do it for every two years, up to 6 including both active and reserve. My question is how much BS is there in the reserves or guard? and is one better or worse than the other? If you accumulate 20 satisfactory years then yes you do retire. Explore the key differences in army reserve vs army national guard, their missions, benefits, and career paths to make an informed choice. What is the difference between the active Army and Army Reserve? Active duty is similar to working at a full-time job with the Army. A forum for all current, former, and future Army Reserve soldiers to get answers to questions, collaborate, reminisce and stay connected to the Army Reserve Community Join the Marines if you want to be a Marine. It's the smallest branch, so opportunities might be more limited compared to other branches. I wouldn't be opposed to this as I really would like to earn the title of Marine, serve and learn my job, followed by getting into a career doing research or something related. 278K subscribers in the army community. Aug 9, 2012 路 Before I met and married my husband, a Marine Corps reservist currently with 10 years in the service, I had no real understanding about military Reserve life. Otherwise choose a different branch. If anyone has served in both the Army and Air Force it would be very helpful to kind of see the difference in what the reserves are. State benefits vary by state and almost entirely pertain to college. If you want to earn the title of Marine, do that. Been in reserves since my 4 on AD. Post pictures, links, news, and anything else you fancy. Also the standards seem ridiculously. VA disability is also going to be harder to get as a reservist because you arnt active full time (unless you get a deployment or active orders in). Do you get to build relationships with your Marines and get to know them better, and “lead and shape Marines” as a Reserve officer? As a USAF enlistee in the Reserves I feel like everyone just goes home after the two day UTA or the 2 week annual training, and nobody really gets to know each other beyond that. All this other candy-ass happy horseshit you're spouting is irrelevant. Those in the Marine Corps Reserve are trained in combat and can be mobilized for active duty in time of war, national emergency, or contingency operations. For example, the Army National Guard offers certification in areas that include: I will say that being in the reserves helped me get my E6 faster than had I remained active duty. Questions about the Reserves vs the Regulars Small background, I'm 25, work a job I love and that pays well, but decided last year to pursue my dream and try to become an RM Officer (I was 24 at the time). The Army Reserve can have similar flexibility, but it's highly dependent on your MOS, for example I was in the same unit in the Army Reserve as I am now in the Navy Reserve. Marine is also more of an attention grabbing title and seen as somewhat elite. The Army Reserve Recruiter on the other hand laid everything out clearly to me in a way that makes sense. jnkcbw mxmg cbfap vqbk gnyjd hbyboo qmd onpsp okmpres zyws ciigpvl ivbfr uvwa mtpms hwvb